The case of Jacque Waller, a 39-year-old mother of three, is a heartbreaking story that highlights the devastating impact of domestic violence and the quest for justice in the face of tragedy. Jacque's disappearance in June 2011 and the subsequent investigation into her death captured national attention and raised awareness about the complexities of abusive relationships. Join me today as I thoroughly examine the details surrounding Jacque Waller's life, her tragic death, the investigation that followed, and the eventual legal proceedings that sought to bring her killer to justice.
Background
Jacque Waller was born on March 20, 1972, in Cape Girardeau, Missouri. She was known for her vibrant personality and dedication to her family. She worked hard as a manager for an insurance company. Jacque was a loving mother to her three triplets and was actively involved in their lives because they were her world. At the time of her disappearance, she was navigating a tumultuous relationship with her estranged husband Clay Waller, which would later become a focal point in the investigation.
Jacque's marriage to her husband, who was also the father of her children, had been marked by conflict and allegations of domestic violence. Despite this, she loved him because he was the father of their children. Friends and family expressed concerns about Jacque's safety, as there were reports of escalating tensions in their relationship. Despite these challenges, Jacque remained committed to her children and sought to create a stable environment for them.
Disappearance
Jacque Waller was last seen on June 1, 2011, when she left her home in the small town of Cape Girardeau. She was reportedly on her way to meet her husband Clay, who she separated from in March of 2011, to sign divorce papers and discuss their ongoing custody issues. During this time, she called her sister Cheryl at 3:50 pm to mention what happened and proceeded to inform her sister she was going to pick up their son Maddox. After that day, Jacque vanished without a trace, prompting her family and friends to worry about her well-being.
Cheryl was upset and knew immediately something was wrong when her sister failed to call her and tell her she was coming home, as she moved in with Cheryl and her husband Robert (or Bob) and was living with them at the time. She was due to be home at around 5:30 pm.
After failing to reach Jacque, her sister Cheryl Brenneke contacted Clay Waller through phone calls and text messages. Following multiple unsuccessful attempts, she left a voicemail on Waller's phone, stating that if she did not receive a response within ten minutes, she would involve the authorities. Waller swiftly returned her call, asserting that the last time he had seen Jacque was at the attorney's office. Cheryl just knew that Clay was involved in her sister’s disappearance and immediately knew she was murdered by him.
The Missouri Police Department launched an extensive search for Jacque, utilizing various resources, including search teams, volunteers, and minor media coverage. The case garnered attention, with local news outlets covering the story and raising awareness about her disappearance. Jacque's family and friends organized search parties and distributed flyers in hopes of finding her.
Investigation
As the investigation progressed, authorities began to focus on Jacque's estranged husband James Clay Waller II, who had a history of domestic violence. He became a person of interest in the case and investigators sought to gather evidence regarding his whereabouts and actions around the time of Jacque's disappearance. It became evident to all that Jacque was a victim of domestic violence and lived in fear of Clay. On one occasion her sister said, “She would not sit on the couch without the curtains being closed for fear he would snipe her from the woods.”
Brenneke, the sister of the victim testified that, before her disappearance on June 1, 2011, Jacque had begun a new relationship with another man, with plans to move in him. Just three days prior to her disappearance, Jacque informed her sister that she had communicated with Clay Waller. Jacque proceeded to tell Cheryl Brenneke, “I just can't do it anymore. If he's going to kill me, he's going to kill me. I can't live like that anymore. That's not living.” Brenneke wanted her sister to go to authorities, but Jacque thought that would just make things worse. In an effort to cover his tracks and reduce his involvement, Clay Waller contacted the Jackson Police Department himself around 12:30 a.m. on June 2, 2011, to file a missing person report for his wife.
Clay informed authorities that he met Jacque at Walgreens around 11 a.m. and they subsequently proceeded to have lunch. He described spending some time apart in town before reuniting at the attorney's office at 3 p.m. to finalize some documents. Clay stated that Jacque returned to his residence to discuss the divorce, acknowledging that they had a disagreement, although he deemed it relatively minor. He indicated that Jacque then walked away from him. Upon searching for her, he returned home to discover that her car was gone, suggesting that she had indeed left.
During this time, it was discovered that Jacque confided into Clay directly about her thoughts of leaving him, also indicating that she intended to take the children with her. In the subsequent year, Clay began to issue a series of threats towards her, instilling profound fear mongering. In response, Jacque maintained a detailed diary at work, documenting his remarks, which included direct threats such as, “Clay told me that I didn't deserve to live and he wishes he had a gun so he could blow my head off that day. He told me that a divorce would be my death sentence,” as well as, alarming statements regarding the children. He ominously suggested that he might take them fishing and allow them to drown, reveling in the idea of conveying this to her.
On May 29, 2013, years after Jacque was reported missing, her remains were discovered in a remote area near the Mississippi River. When the authorities discovered Jacque's car, which initially seemed to have experienced a blown tire. This prompted an investigation into the possibility that she had either taken a ride with someone, called for help, or been abducted. However, a more thorough examination of the tire revealed that it had been punctured while the vehicle was stationary, rather than as a result of driving over an object.
The discovery confirmed the worst fears of her family and friends and the investigation quickly shifted from a missing persons case to a homicide investigation.
Arrest of the Estranged Husband
Following the discovery of Jacque's remains, her estranged husband James was arrested and charged with her murder. The evidence gathered during the investigation pointed to his involvement in her death, leading to a strong case against him.
Clay’s own actions ultimately precipitated his downfall. Fueled by an inflated ego and deep-seated angst, he was acutely aware of his misconduct and sought to draw indirect attention from others. He brazenly taunted both the police and Jacque’s family, dismissing their efforts by asserting that they would uncover nothing. His arrogance manifested in juvenile acts, such as honking his horn as he drove past their residences while making offensive gestures toward law enforcement.
Clay's vindictive demeanor and proclivity for negativity compelled him to consistently make disparaging remarks, driven by an insatiable need to have the last word and issue threats. This behavior intensified when, four months after Jacque’s disappearance, the court awarded custody of the triplets to Cheryl. In a fit of rage, he issued a threat on social media on July 26, 2011, saying, “You are dead I promise If those kids get hurt, your fault, accident, nobodys fault. Your dad threaten clay, I know he's all talk, I will get you 5, 10, 25 years from now. You have it coming.” In that moment, he irrevocably sealed his own fate.
The police scrutinized Waller's account of the day Jacque Waller disappeared. CCTV footage corroborated that he met Jacque at Walgreens at around 11 a.m. and recorded her presence at 2 p.m., marking the last confirmed sighting of her alive. Subsequently, investigators discovered footage of Clay Waller later that evening; he was at a toy store dressed in different attire than he had worn earlier that day. Further footage showed Clay engaging in the act of washing his boat.
Legal Proceedings
The trial of Jacque Waller's estranged husband began in 2013. The prosecution presented evidence that included witness testimony, forensic evidence, and details about the couple's tumultuous relationship. The defense argued that there was insufficient evidence to prove his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, which I notice seems common in domestic abuse murder cases.
In 2013, Clay was apprehended on federal charges for threatening Cheryl's life. He entered a plea of guilty to this charge, resulting in a five-year prison sentence. This removal of a dangerous individual from society not only safeguarded the community, but also afforded law enforcement the time required to construct a case against him in connection with Jacque's disappearance. Due to the lack of a body, investigators and prosecutors had to meticulously build a robust case founded on circumstantial evidence, a process that ultimately took two years to complete.
Jacque's estranged husband pled guilty and therefore was found guilty of second-degree murder. Clay was offered a plea deal, which was made with the consent of Jacque's parents, whose foremost priority was to recover their daughter. The agreement stipulated that Clay could plead guilty to second-degree murder and receive a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison, contingent upon his cooperation in revealing the events of that night and the whereabouts of Jacque's remains.
He subsequently guided authorities to Devil's Island. Upon reaching Devil's Island, the victim’s estranged husband was unable to pinpoint the exact location where he had buried Jacque. While he acknowledged that her body lay somewhere in the vicinity, he could not provide a specific reference. However, one astute officer managed to ascertain the area. Clay had mentioned the use of fertilizer, which prompted this officer to consider its impact on tree roots.
Using this information, they identified a dead tree, ultimately leading to the discovery of Jacque's body. This pivotal moment took place on May 29, 2013, nearly two years following Jacque's disappearance. The verdict brought a sense of closure to Jacque's family and friends, who had endured months of uncertainty, emotional pain, and grief. Personally, he should have been given life in prison without any possibility of parole; however, this is the law sadly.
More Into The Investigation
Court documents reveal that Cheryl, Jacque's sister, stated that at one point in early 2011, Clay Waller told Jacque, “You think you're safe up there at your sister's. Well, you're not. I'll just wait for you to have to go to town and get you going to the grocery store.”
As law enforcement continued to investigate this case, they noticed that Clay demonstrated significant deceitfulness and hatred, recounting a series of implausible narratives. In one particular version of events, he alleged that Jacque wished to come to his house for one final sexual encounter prior to their divorce being finalized. According to his account, while they were together in the kitchen, they inadvertently bumped heads, resulting in Jacque’s nose to bleed. He claimed that she then proceeded into the hallway, which accounted for the blood authorities found there.
He further asserted that Jacque began to threaten him, stating that he would never see their children again and that she would tell everyone he physically and mentally abused her, which purportedly led him to lose control. Clay stated that he struck her once in the nose and pressed his forearm against her neck until she became unresponsive. He characterized his decision to kill Jacque as impulsive and unpremeditated, asserting that it was a direct reaction to her threats regarding their children.
One of the most oddest things was Clay Waller informed the police that the day before, he had dug a hole for Jacque's body, which contradicted his earlier claim that he spontaneously decided to kill her that day. More critically, by digging the hole, he had crossed state lines into Illinois with the intention of committing murder. This action subjected him to more charges under the Interstate Domestic Violence Act, which carries a maximum sentence of 35 years, with the term commencing only after the completion of any prior 20-year sentence. As of 2017, he has been sentenced to 35 years in prison.
Impact and Awareness
The tragic case of Jacque Waller highlights the importance of raising awareness about domestic violence and the potential dangers faced by individuals in abusive relationships. Her story serves as a reminder of the need for support systems and resources for those affected by domestic violence.
In the wake of Jacque's disappearance and murder, the Cape Girardeau community rallied together to support her family and raise awareness about the issue of domestic violence. Community organizations and advocates worked to provide resources and support for victims, emphasizing the importance of speaking out and seeking help.
The case of Jacque Waller is a heartbreaking reminder of the complexities of domestic violence and the tragic consequences it can have on individuals and families. Her disappearance and subsequent murder brought attention to the urgent need for awareness and action against domestic abuse.
While Jacque's story ended in tragedy, it serves as a catalyst for change, encouraging communities to support victims and work toward preventing future violence against women. By sharing her story, it is imperative to honor her memory and strive to create a safer world for those affected by domestic violence.
Comments