The Best Pizzerias in NYC

Best Pizza in NYC

New York City is a culinary paradise, and its pizza scene is among the most celebrated in the world. From classic slices to artisanal pies, NYC boasts an array of pizzerias that reflect the city’s diverse flavors and traditions. Join me today as I explore some of the best pizzerias you must try when you're in the Big Apple.

1. Andiamo Pizza

Location: 818 6th Ave, New York, NY  

Contact: (212) 254-2680  


Andiamo Pizza offers a mouthwatering mix of traditional and innovative flavors. Known for their classic Margherita and unique white pizza options, the crust is crispy and perfectly charred. The cozy, casual atmosphere encourages diners to relax and savor their meals. The attentive service adds to the experience, making Andiamo a favorite among locals and visitors alike.


2. Ribalta

Location: 48 E 12th St, New York, NY  

Contact: (212) 777-7781  


Ribalta specializes in Neapolitan-style pizza with an upscale twist. Each pizza features high-quality ingredients, and the vibrant, airy space is ideal for casual dining. Signature offerings like the "Ribalta Pizza" with sausage and mushrooms leave a lasting impression. The knowledgeable staff provides excellent service, making it a must-visit spot.


3. AMICI

Location: 164 Mulberry St, New York, NY  

Contact: (212) 203-2766  


Nestled in Little Italy, AMICI serves a delightful variety of pizzas, from classic pepperoni to unique creations like the "Truffle White Pizza." The lively atmosphere is perfect for a night out, and the friendly staff enhances the dining experience. The pizza’s rich flavors and quality toppings make it a popular choice.


4. Eataly

Location: 101 Liberty St, New York, NY  

Contact: (212) 897-2895  


This Italian marketplace features a pizzeria that serves an array of traditional pizzas made with fresh ingredients sourced from Italy. Eataly’s ambiance is vibrant and bustling, filled with food enthusiasts. Their wood-fired pizzas, especially the "Funghi," are a fan favorite and the knowledgeable staff makes recommendations easy.


5. Juliana’s

Location: 19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY (Approx. 3 miles from NYC)  

Contact: (718) 596-6700  


Founded by pizza pioneer Patsy Grimaldi, Juliana's offers a distinct and delicious take on coal-fired pizza. The restaurant maintains a retro vibe with charming decor. Menu highlights include the classic "Margherita" and the "White Pizza," both of which are consistently praised for their flavors and texture. The attentive staff and warm environment make for an enjoyable dining experience.


6. Lucali

Location: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY (Approx. 3 miles from NYC)  

Contact: (718) 858-4086  


Lucali is renowned for its artisanal pizzas and warm, inviting atmosphere. The flagship "Margherita" pizza impresses anyone who enjoys it with its simple elegance featuring fresh mozzarella and basil. Be prepared for possible waits, but the friendly service and exquisite food are worth it. The charming candlelit environment sets the perfect backdrop for a night out.


7. Angelo’s Pizza

Location: 117 W 57th St, New York, NY  

Contact: (212) 333-4333  


Angelo’s remains a quintessential New York slice spot. Famous for its classic toppings and generous portions, the cheese slice is truly a must-try. The casual atmosphere encourages quick bites, and the efficient service keeps things moving smoothly. Don’t miss their garlic knots, which are another highlight.


8. Lombardi’s Pizza

Location: 32 Spring St, New York, NY  

Contact: (212) 941-7994  


Dubbed America’s first pizzeria, Lombardi’s offers time-honored slices and a historical ambiance. Their coal-oven-baked pizzas have a distinct flavor, with the "Margherita" being a standout. The bustling environment and attentive staff make it a perfect destination for pizza lovers eager to indulge in a piece of NYC history.


9. Milkflower

Location: 34-12 31st Ave, Astoria, NY (Approx. 8 miles from NYC)  

Contact: (718) 204-1300  


Milkflower serves artisanal pizza with unique flavor combinations, like the "Fennel Sausage" and "Roasted Garlic." The rustic-chic decor and warm atmosphere invite diners to unwind. Friendly service enhances the experience, making it an excellent spot for family dinners or gatherings with friends.


10. Joe & Sal’s Pizza

Location: 842 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY (Approx. 5 miles from NYC)  

Contact: (718) 484-8732  


A local favorite, Joe & Sal’s Pizza delivers classic New York slices that are both affordable and delicious. Their "Pepperoni Pizza" is popular among regulars. The laid-back, no-frills environment makes it perfect for a casual pizza night, and the staff is always ready to offer a friendly smile.


New York City’s pizzerias are a testament to the city’s vibrant culinary scene. Each of these establishments offers something unique, from traditional recipes to innovative toppings. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, make sure to dive into the incredible world of NYC pizza. You won’t be disappointed.

Comments