The Best Place to Find an Ice Cream Sundae in NYC

Best Place to Find an Ice Cream Sundae in NYC

When it comes to indulging your sweet tooth in New York City, few desserts evoke the nostalgic delight of an ice cream sundae. This quintessential treat appeals to a wide range of preferences, whether you lean toward a classic hot fudge sundae generously topped with whipped cream or seek out more adventurous combinations featuring unique flavors and toppings. NYC’s vibrant dessert scene showcases an impressive variety of ice cream parlors and dessert cafes, each offering their distinct twist on this beloved delicacy. With such an array of choices, you’re guaranteed to find the perfect sundae to satisfy your cravings in the city. From iconic establishments to hidden gems, join me today as I take you through only a thorough exploration of the best places to savor an ice cream sundae in the big apple.

1. Eddie’s Sweet Shop

- Location: 105-29 Metropolitan Ave 1, Forest Hills, NY

- Contact: (718) 520-8514

- Distance from Downtown: Approximately 11 miles


Specialties


Known for their old-fashioned sundaes, Eddie's offers a charming menu featuring the classic Hot Fudge Sundae made with homemade fudge and rich vanilla ice cream.


Food Impressions


Customers rave about the quality and nostalgic flavor of the sundaes, noting the generous portions that create a satisfying experience.


Ambiance Impressions


Stepping into Eddie's feels like a trip back in time, with vintage decor and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere.


Service Impressions


The service is friendly and efficient, with staff eager to help choose the perfect sundae.


Reasons to Dine Here


A perfect spot for families and ice cream enthusiasts looking for classic flavors in a nostalgic setting. They only accept cash. 


2. Serendipity 3

- Location: 225 E 60th St, New York, NY

- Contact: (212) 838-3531


Specialties


Famous for its extravagant sundaes, Serendipity 3 serves the indulgent Frrrozen Hot Chocolate Sundae, a decadent mix of chocolate ice cream and frozen hot chocolate topped with whipped cream.


Food Impressions


Visitors often remark on the sheer delight of the whimsical presentations and indulgent flavors that make each bite memorable.


Ambiance Impressions


Quirky and whimsical decor adds to the charm, making it a fun destination for both families and romantic outings.


Service Impressions


The atmosphere is lively, and while it can get busy, the staff is generally attentive and friendly.


Reasons to Dine Here


Perfect for those wanting to indulge in a creatively designed sundae in a vibrant, iconic New York setting.


3. Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream

- Location: 88 W Houston St, New York, NY

- Contact: (212) 209-7684


Specialties


Their original sundaes feature flavors like Mango Sticky Rice and Black Sesame, crafted from high-quality, locally sourced ingredients.


Food Impressions


Diners consistently praise the sumptuous textures and bold, inventive flavor combinations, with many landing on Morgenstern’s as a go-to for premium ice cream.


Ambiance Impressions


Minimalist yet stylish, the shop has a contemporary vibe that pairs well with its artisanal approach to ice cream.


Service Impressions


Staff are knowledgeable and enthusiastic about the flavors, keen to make recommendations to enhance the experience.


Reasons to Dine Here


Ideal for adventurous eaters looking for gourmet flavors in a sophisticated, modern setting.


4. Carvel

- Location: 165 W 48th St, New York, NY

- Contact: (212) 300-4090


Specialties


A classic American chain, Carvel is known for its soft-serve sundaes, particularly the classic Fudgie the Whale, which brings nostalgia to many.


Food Impressions


With its velvety texture and rich flavor, customers often appreciate the consistency and quality of the soft-serve ice cream.


Ambiance Impressions


Casual and straightforward, the shop allows customers to focus on their treat without distractions.


Service Impressions


Quick and efficient service makes it a convenient stop for those on the go.


Reasons to Dine Here


Perfect for families and anyone seeking familiar, comforting flavors in a no-frills environment.


5. Sugarhill Creamery

- Location: 3629 Broadway, New York, NY

- Contact: (212) 634-9004 ext. 4


Specialties


Sugarhill is celebrated for its unique flavors like Sweet Potato Cake and Cornbread, offering a creative spin on traditional sundae toppings.


Food Impressions


Diners often remark on the innovative flavor options that invoke local and cultural inspirations, providing a distinctive twist to their sundaes.


Ambiance Impressions


Bright and colorful decor reflects the joyous spirit of the flavors, creating an inviting space to enjoy sweets.


Service Impressions


Staff members are friendly and happy to provide recommendations, creating a welcoming atmosphere.


Reasons to Dine Here


A must-visit for those wanting to explore unique, culturally inspired flavors in a lively setting.


6. Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

- Location: 513 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY

- Contact: (718) 522-6260

- Distance from NYC: Approximately 4 miles


Specialties


A nod to vintage soda fountains, Brooklyn Farmacy offers sundaes made with artisanal ice cream and house-made toppings like hot fudge and caramel.


Food Impressions


The focus on high-quality ingredients shines through in the flavors, with many guests striving to try multiple sundaes on each visit.


Ambiance Impressions


The charming, retro decor lends itself to a cozy and inviting vibe, perfect for relaxing with friends or family.


Service Impressions


Friendly and knowledgeable, staff are eager to guide customers through the menu.


Reasons to Dine Here


Ideal for those who appreciate nostalgia alongside delicious sweets, Brooklyn Farmacy creates a delightful trip down memory lane.


7. The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory

- Location: 65 Bayard St, New York, NY

- Contact: (212) 608-4170


Specialties


Known for its Asian-inspired flavors, the shop offers sundaes with unique options like Lychee and Red Bean, making it a standout for those looking to experiment.


Food Impressions


Diners are often impressed by the balance of flavors that transcend typical ice cream offerings.


Ambiance Impressions


The vibrant and lively atmosphere reflects the bustling Chinatown locale, making for an exciting visit.


Service Impressions


The staff is friendly and enthusiastic about introducing guests to the exotic flavors.


Reasons to Dine Here


A perfect choice for adventurous ice cream lovers seeking unique flavor combinations in a lively setting.


8. Ample Hills Creamery at The Social

- Location: 816 Washington Ave, Brooklyn, NY

- Contact: (347) 427-3016

- Distance from NYC: Approximately 5 miles


Specialties


Ample Hills is known for its rich and creamy ice cream, with popular sundae options like the Ooey Gooey Butter Cake that highlight their homemade recipes.


Food Impressions


Guests often rave about the intense flavors and creamy texture of the ice cream, making each sundae an indulgent treat.


Ambiance Impressions


A welcoming, colorful environment reflects the playful spirit of the brand, making it an inviting place for families.


Service Impressions


Staff are engaging and always ready to help create the perfect sundae for every customer.


Reasons to Dine Here


A delightful stop for families and friends looking for a fun place to enjoy handcrafted ice cream creations.


9. Emack & Bolio’s Ice Cream

- Location: 1005 2nd Ave, New York, NY

- Contact: (646) 398-9939


Specialties


Known for their over-the-top sundaes, Emack & Bolio’s offers unique flavor combinations like the Peanut Butter Cup and the Rocky Road Explosion.


Food Impressions


Diners find themselves transported by the creative approaches to classic sundaes, ensuring each spoonful is bursting with flavor.


Ambiance Impressions


The shop has a funky, vibrant decor that makes for an exciting visit, with an atmosphere that encourages indulgence.


Service Impressions


Staff are friendly and encouraging, always happy to walk customers through their elaborate sundae options.


Reasons to Dine Here


For those who appreciate a whimsical dining experience paired with unique flavors, Emack & Bolio’s is not to be missed.


10. Ice Cream House

- Location: 873 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY

- Contact: (718) 972-0222

- Distance from NYC: Approximately 5 miles


Specialties


Ice Cream House focuses on classic sundaes but often tweaks traditional recipes with seasonal toppings and flavors.


Food Impressions


Variety is paramount in this establishment, with guests frequently praising the quality and freshness of the ingredients.


Ambiance Impressions


The cozy, laid-back environment provides a perfect backdrop for a casual dessert outing.


Service Impressions


The staff maintains a welcoming and supportive demeanor, ensuring that each guest has an exceptional experience.


Reasons to Dine Here


A charming neighborhood spot where you can kick back and enjoy classic sundaes reimagined.


With such an exciting array of ice cream parlors offering artisanal sundaes, New York City is truly a dessert lover's paradise. From old-school favorites at Eddie's Sweet Shop to the innovative treats at Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream, there’s no shortage of delectable experiences waiting to be savored. Each establishment brings its own unique flair, making a sundae not just a dessert, but a celebration of flavors and creativity. So, whether you're a die-hard sundae fanatic or just looking for a sweet escape, the ice cream sundae scene in NYC promises to delight your taste buds and keep you coming back for more. 

Comments